Debt or equity: which is right for your business?
How debt and equity financing compare on cost, control and risk, and where structured capital and recapitalisations fit.
In short. Debt financing means borrowing money that must be repaid with interest, without giving up ownership. Equity financing means selling a share of the business to investors, who share in the upside and the risk but are not repaid on a schedule. Debt is usually cheaper and leaves control with the owners, but it needs predictable cash flow. Equity costs more over time but carries no repayments, which suits a business investing ahead of its earnings. Many businesses use both, and structured capital sits in between.
What is the difference between debt and equity financing?
The difference is what the provider gets in return. A lender gets interest and repayment on agreed dates; an equity investor gets a share of the ownership and of the future value.
| Debt | Equity | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | Interest and fees, usually lower than the return equity investors expect | A share of future value, usually the most expensive capital over time |
| Control | Owners keep their shares; covenants set limits | Investors own part of the business and agree rights over key decisions |
| Repayment | On a schedule, whatever the year brings | No scheduled repayment; investors are paid through dividends or on exit |
| Security | Often secured on assets or shares | Unsecured; investors rank behind lenders |
| Who provides it | Banks, private credit funds and other lenders | Family offices, private equity, venture capital, strategic and angel investors |
| Best suited to | Businesses with steady cash flow or assets | Businesses investing ahead of earnings, or looking for a partner |
In many countries interest can be deducted for tax, within limits, which lowers the cost of debt further. Take tax advice on how this applies to your business.
When is debt the better choice?
Debt is usually the better choice when the business has predictable cash flow that comfortably covers interest and repayments, and the owners want to keep their full shareholding.
Typical situations include:
- Funding a specific investment with a clear return, such as equipment, a new site or an acquisition.
- Refinancing existing borrowing on better terms.
- Financing working capital in a business with steady, contracted revenue.
- Returning money to shareholders without bringing in a new owner (see recapitalisations below).
The risk is that debt has to be paid whatever happens. A business with seasonal or volatile earnings can breach its covenants in a bad year, and the lenders then have a strong say in what happens next. Size borrowing to the cash flow in a difficult year, not a good one.
When is equity the better choice?
Equity is usually the better choice when the business needs capital it cannot yet repay from its cash flow, or when the owners want a partner as well as money.
Typical situations include:
- Investing ahead of revenue, for example in a new market, product or team.
- Growth plans larger than lenders will fund.
- A business with uneven or unproven cash flow.
- An investor whose experience, network or access to markets adds value. Family offices often fit here, as we explain in Family offices: what they are and how to approach one.
- Giving some shareholders liquidity through a partial sale.
The cost is a share of future value and, depending on the terms, of control. How the stake is calculated, and which terms matter as much as the percentage, is covered in How much equity should you give investors?
What is structured or hybrid capital?
Structured capital combines features of debt and equity, so it can be shaped to the business rather than fitted to a template. The most common forms are:
- Mezzanine debt. Ranks behind the senior lenders and ahead of the shareholders, with a higher interest rate and sometimes a small equity element.
- Preferred equity. Shares with a priority return or a preference over ordinary shares, often with fewer control rights than a full equity investment.
- Convertible loans. Loans that can turn into shares later, often at a discount to the price of the next round.
- Unitranche facilities. A single loan, often from a private credit fund, that combines senior and junior debt under one set of terms.
These instruments are useful where pure debt is too much for the cash flow and pure equity gives up too much ownership. They are also more complex to negotiate, so the terms need reading as carefully as the headline rate.
What is a recapitalisation?
A recapitalisation changes the mix of debt and equity in a business. It is often used to release value to shareholders while keeping the business properly funded for what comes next.
Common forms include:
- A dividend recapitalisation. The business borrows and uses part of the proceeds to pay a dividend to its shareholders.
- A partial sale. A new investor buys some of the existing shares, giving some owners liquidity while others stay invested.
- A balance sheet reset. New equity or longer-term debt replaces borrowing that no longer suits the business.
The right structure depends on what the shareholders want: cash now, a partner for the next stage, or a stronger balance sheet. Recapitalisations and shareholder liquidity are part of our private capital work.
How do private credit funds lend to private companies?
Private credit funds are investment funds that lend directly to companies rather than through a bank. For mid-sized private businesses, they are an alternative or a complement to bank lending.
Compared with a bank, a private credit fund will often:
- Lend against cash flow rather than mainly against assets.
- Offer more flexible structures, including unitranche facilities and repayment profiles shaped to the business.
- Decide through a small investment team rather than a syndicate of banks.
- Charge a higher interest rate in return for that flexibility.
As with equity, the lender’s fit matters: the size of loan it makes, the sectors it understands and how it behaves if the business has a difficult year. We arrange senior, unitranche and structured facilities from banks and private credit funds, matched to cash flow rather than to a template.
How do you decide between debt and equity?
Start from the business and its owners, not from what is on offer. Four questions usually decide it:
- What is the money for, and when will it pay back? Capital that produces cash quickly suits debt; capital invested for the long term suits equity.
- How predictable is the cash flow? Debt needs repayments to be met in a bad year as well as a good one.
- How much control do the owners want to keep? Debt adds no shareholders; equity does.
- Do the owners want a partner? Some investors bring experience and access worth more than the difference in cost.
Many raises combine both: senior debt for what the cash flow can carry, and equity or structured capital for the rest. Our guide to how to raise capital for a business sets out the full process, from first assessment to funds received.
Frequently asked questions
Is debt cheaper than equity?
Usually, yes. Lenders take less risk than equity investors because they are repaid first and often hold security, so they accept a lower return. Equity becomes the better choice when the business cannot safely carry the repayments.
What is growth capital?
Growth capital is investment in an established business to fund expansion, such as new markets, sites, products or acquisitions. It is often a minority equity investment, but it can also be provided as debt or structured capital.
Can you raise debt and equity at the same time?
Yes. Many transactions combine senior debt, sometimes structured capital, and equity. The lenders and investors will need to agree how they rank against each other.
What is a covenant?
A covenant is a condition in a loan agreement that the borrower must keep to, such as a maximum level of debt relative to earnings or a minimum level of cash. A breach gives the lender rights, which can include demanding early repayment.
What is the difference between senior debt and mezzanine debt?
Senior debt is repaid first and is usually secured, so it carries the lowest interest rate. Mezzanine debt ranks behind it and ahead of the shareholders, so it carries more risk and a higher rate.
Read next.
All insightsPrivate credit and debt finance: a guide for private companies
Which kinds of debt a founder-owned business can raise without a private equity owner, and how lenders decide how much to lend.
10 minute read
How to sell part of your business without selling the company
The routes to taking money off the table while you keep the company, from a secondary sale to a dividend recapitalisation, and what each one needs.
10 minute read
How much equity should you give investors?
How an investor’s stake is calculated, what dilution means, and the terms that matter as much as the percentage.
7 minute read
If this is on your horizon.
A confidential first conversation costs nothing and changes what is possible.
Book a confidential callThirty minutes. Strictly confidential. No cost or obligation.
Senior attention, from the first conversation to completion.
- We prepare first
We read what you send before the call, so the conversation starts with your business, not ours.
- A candid view
Of your market position, the natural buyers or investors, and what to do first.
- Confirmed straight away
A calendar invitation with a Google Meet link. Everything you share stays within the firm, whether or not we are engaged.
